Now that January is over, it’s time for me to share my final thoughts on the Episcopal Church. Ok, I will probably be writing about the church again at some point this year, but these are the official final thoughts.
I have absolutely loved diving into the Episcopal Church. I am so thankful for St. John’s; they were so willing to answer questions and share their stories with me.
This month, I discovered that some of my initial assumptions were actually pretty accurate. The Episcopal Church is “Catholic Light” – but my understanding of that term has changed. I didn’t know the history behind the church, and how it emerged as a middle way between the Catholic and Protestant beliefs. The Episcopal Church is an Anglican Church, a descendant of the Church of England. Because of this, they have retained some Catholic traditions. The use of sacraments and liturgy remind people of the church’s Catholic past; the leadership of deacons, priests, and bishops strikes fear in the heart of low church devotees. But the Episcopal Church chose not to retain the authoritarian structure of the Catholic Church. There is no Pope; instead, it is a democracy. The Episcopal Church also allows clergy to marry, and for both men and women to hold positions of leadership. This further separates them from the Catholic Church.
But not all my assumptions were correct. I thought all the ritual and liturgy meant the Episcopal Church was strict and based on rules. Turns out they are better defined as liturgically high and liberally low. I had mistaken structure for strictness. Yes, because of its similarities to the Catholic Church, the Episcopal Church can be misleading. They follow the Book of Common Prayer in their services, and rarely, if ever, stray from it. But that doesn’t mean they are strict. You will never hear fire and brimstone preached from the pulpit; you won’t be commanded to avoid certain sins. The Episcopal Church believes in embracing life. That means they aren’t opposed to enjoying the occasional glass of wine or game of poker. (Ever heard the phrase “Episcopal guilt”? No, no you haven’t.)
I’ve learned that the Episcopal Church is an intellectual one, always open to questions and suggestions. It is a church that strives for social justice and equality for all, but above all else, it desires to be a home for its members. Unlike the Roman Catholic Church or the Church of Latter-day Saints, the Episcopal Church doesn’t advertise. They are a church for seekers. They won’t force their beliefs on you; instead, they welcome new faces and opinions.
There are some things about the Episcopal Church that give me pause, though. I have always loved praise and worship at churches I’ve attended. Singing “How He Loves” with my hands lifted just does something for my soul. But the Episcopal Church is strictly hymns, at least during their services. The priest I talked to even discussed how much musical tradition was lost in the formation and changes of the church. Also, and this is just my opinion, I think the Episcopal Church prefers hymns and quiet praise because they are very into reason over emotions. In fact, in Those Episkopols by Dennis Maynard, he says “(s)eeking some sort of emotional experience is outside the Anglican tradition”. I think it is wise to rely on knowledge instead of feeling, but I do think emotions belong in the church. I want to worship with my head and my heart.
Overall, though, I could see myself finding a home in the Episcopal Church. I would just have to listen to “How He Loves” at home

Pingback: An Intentional January | J Bryant Writes
I’ve often said that if, for some reason, I were to leave the Presbyterian church, the Episcopal church would be my next choice. And that from someone who grew up Assembly of God.
I wasn’t expecting to like the Episcopal church that much, but I totally did! I’ll be visiting the Presbyterian church this fall – looking forward to it.
Thank you for teaching me so much about the Episcopal church. I really knew next to nothing before this series. I can’t believe how much my attitudes about church services have changed in the last few years. Five years ago I never would have considered “high church” something I could like. After this series, maybe I could. Thanks.
Thanks for reading about it! I’m glad I’m able to share what I’m learning; I knew so little about “high church” before I started this, and I can’t wait to visit more churches.
Thanks for writing; I enjoy your blogs. For your reason and emotion comment, I would just note that for many people, myself included, hymns do stir the emotions and do things for the soul that other music doesn’t (although I definitely enjoy “How He Loves”).
Thanks for commenting, John. I suppose I should have phrased my thoughts a little better – I absolutely think hymns can stir emotion. There are hymns that I love as much as modern songs. Perhaps it was more about my lack of familiarity with the service and the words of the hymns than the hymns themselves…
You want to start a fight with church people, bring up opinions on music and worship.
I love hymns; I love contemporary songs; I love choral pieces. I’m one of those who just loves music. I will say, however, that a diet of hymns-and-only-hymns would still nourish my soul, where a diet of praise-songs-and-only-praise-songs would not.
Buuuut that’s because guess what denomination is also an intellectual-more-than-emotional one? Lutherans, duh. Which is funny because Luther was this wild guy who saw devils and threw ink wells at them and things. I like to say that if you could personality-type denominations, Lutherans would be introverts: calm, quiet, orderly. Not too keen on hugging or shouting or talking out of turn or waving your hands in the air like you care very, very much. So it fits very nicely with my personality type.
Oh, I was going to say on your first impressions post but decided that I was spamming you enough that I thought it was funny that you had an impression of Episcopalians as very strict and rulesy. I always had this impression of them as being awfully wishy-washy, maybe one step too close to the “there are many paths to god (lowercase g) and your truth is as good as mine” mindset.
So it was interesting to read about your experiences and your insight into this “seeker” mindset that doesn’t force its beliefs on others but still, I think, holds to a firm core of truth. Yours are not the only prejudices being confronted through this blog!
Thanks so much for all your spamming
I’ve totally appreciated reading your thoughts, and I’m glad I was able to help you understand the Episcopal church a bit more. It’s funny how differently each person views these denominations – some of the stereotypes can be so different!
Pingback: Visiting an ELCA Church « churchandthesinglegirl